Am I getting behind the curve?

Yesterday I took part in a survey I found through the Digital Birmingham site, called the Digital Curve.

It’s a lighthearted attempt to encourage people to use digital technology and to find out where they sit in comparison to other people when it comes to their ‘digital savviness’.

So, I answered a series of questions about how often I use various media devices - computer, phone, digital tv, games console etc. and out popped my rating. Apparently I’m a “digital superstar”:

Digital Curve 1 results

Digital Curve 2 results

My reaction - “How come I only got 80%?”

For some reason I have come out as having only a 55% score for “Digital Television” and 75% for “Multimedia” (err, didn’t Multimedia go out with the CD-ROM?!)

I’d guess that because I answered ‘never’ for “How often do you use your digital TV to check your email?” and “How often do you use your digital TV to browse for news and job listings?” I got marked down.

Picture this: I’m sitting in my front room with my Apple MacBook Pro, playing iTunes wirelessly via my AirTunes-enabled wireless network directly into my dolby surroundsound music system, my BlackBerry is charging on the table next to me. I decide to watch some TV so I hit pause on the Mac’s remote control and fire up the widescreen TV with brand new Virgin cable digibox. Being a bit non-plussed about what’s currently on the schedule (which I check using TvGuide on the Firefox window that’s permanently open on my Mac) I buy an on-demand movie from the 1000 films available (I’m sure I remember something called Lovefilm) and sit back and enjoy.

At what point would I think “oh hang on, stop the film! I’ve got to check my email! I know - I’ll dig out that oversized TV keyboard and use a low resolution screen that’s about six feet away from me and attempt to access gmail which probably won’t work because it’s all javascripty anyway”.

Does anyone actually use TV email? The vast majority of mobile phones nowadays are internet enabled and I regularly use mine with a Java Gmail client to get emails on the go. And if I were going to check my mail I’d reach over and hit refresh in Firefox.

I just can’t see the point in TV email - am I getting old? Probably.

And I think on the Multimedia front I lost a few points by saying (heavens forfend) I don’t have a cameraphone. Instead, I have a 10 megapixel Leica that I take pretty much everywhere, and when I want to do serious photography I’ll pull out the Canon 5D (or the Hasselblad).

There wasn’t a question about “Do you have an online photosharing site?”, but if there were I’m sure it would bring back a few missing points. A cameraphone is for snaps, using Flickr/Photobucket to share those photos with other people is one step beyond.

There were a few other glaring omissions I’d like to suggest filling: “How many times a day do you update your blog?”,  “How many RSS feeds do you subscribe to?” or if we’re feeling generous “Do you enjoy playing your limited 512MB dubstep MP3 collection using the low quality, tinny loudspeaker on your mobile phone whilst hanging round your neck and sitting on the bus?”

Joking aside, use of digital technology is a very personal thing. Everyone uses things that fit a need within their lives, so whilst the idea of a Digital Curve is valid in some respects, a position in the curve for me is more about awareness of what you might be able to do rather than the media device you use to access your digital content and services. So I guess this is useful for people who aren’t aware of what’s out there, but for me it felt like it didn’t go far enough for the people who are actually using this stuff on a daily basis. There are people much younger than me who know a hell of a lot more about what’s happening with digital media, because they use things in very different ways to how I do.

So perhaps I’m getting behind the curve - better get myself one of those mobile neckstraps (the one with a blue light) and transfer my copy of the Burial album onto my phone. “How loud does this thing go anyway?”

6 Comments

  1. July 27, 2007 at 4:57 pm | Permalink

    A couple of years ago I spent more time than I’d care to remember testing tv email for a certain telecomms company. It was incredibly tedious, made all the more grim by the thought that no-one would ever use this system.

  2. July 27, 2007 at 7:45 pm | Permalink

    I got 70%. Which kinda renders the whole thing pointless.

    For the “why don’t you use digital TV” there wasn’t an option for “I download what I watch using BitTorrent”. And apparently not using my mobile to access the web is a problem, even though I have a computer for that.

    On the other hand it’s nice to see I’m still an outsider in this new digital world. ;)

  3. July 28, 2007 at 12:26 pm | Permalink

    It occurs me to later than the point of this exercise is to show people who don’t consider themselves to be “digital” that they actually are. For example, people who video their children on their phones and send those clips to their parents don’t think of themselves as digital film producers and distributors, but they are, in a way.

    That would make more sense regarding Digital Birmingham’s mission statement thingy.

  4. John Henry Mostyn
    July 29, 2007 at 1:04 pm | Permalink

    Good point Pete..

    The survey brings up some interesting points on convergence - you rightly question the tv/email, but because it is so linear, there isn’t an option for say mobile/music..

    Vodafone and Apple are both making pushes for Youtube on your mobile - do you think ‘internet video’ (I guess loosley defined as short length and mega eclectic) will be accepted on the mobile or TV (lots of interface/usability issues to overcome)..

  5. July 30, 2007 at 10:22 am | Permalink

    Do you enjoy playing your limited 512MB dubstep MP3 collection using the low quality, tinny loudspeaker on your mobile phone whilst hanging round your neck and sitting on the bus?

    Should one get extra points for doing the same in the Prince of Wales Beer Garden?

    This causes me give up on my beer, go home and fiddle with my laptop instead, hence causing a knock-on digital effect.

  6. beadle
    August 2, 2007 at 7:55 pm | Permalink

    Firstly, enough with ‘digital’ technology. It’s technology. I never invited people to use my analogue camera, listen to my analogue record player or even my digital CD’s. It’s a brand name for mugs. Secondly, suggesting that people who use video on their phones are film producers and distributers is as absurd as saying that people that walk up Snowdon are mountain climbers, or that people wearing Vans are skateboarders. Yes, you have problems determining reality. I won’t blame you, I’ll blame language, as it hasn’t seen fit to designate a proper term for people using videophones. Personally I just call them ‘people with phones.’ If recognising the differences between Bergman (RIP) and a 14 yr old happy slapper is too difficult I suggest shutting down some of that technology and going for a long walk in the country. Or better still, find an analogue woman.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*